From Liquidator to Contemnor:
How a Failed Lawsuit Led to Committal Proceedings Against a Liquidator
While every witness owes a solemn duty to tell the truth, court-appointed liquidators are held to a heightened duty to the court as officers of the court. The Hong Kong Court of First Instance recently underscored these principles in NHD Systems (Asia) Limited (In Liquidation) v Li Xiao Yi [2025] HKCFI 408 and Li Xiao Yi v Tang Chung Wah [2026] HKCFI 4283. This pair of closely linked decisions shows how a failed civil action to recover an alleged 32-year-old loan ultimately led to a liquidator facing criminal committal proceedings for lying under oath.
Background
The dispute arose when Tang Chung Wah (“Tang“), a liquidator of the company placed into compulsory liquidation, namely, NHD Systems (Asia) Limited (In Liquidation) (the “Company”), sought to recover an alleged US$1 million loan said to have been advanced to Li Xiao Yi in 1992. The Company’s claim ultimately failed at trial. However, the court’s concerns extended far beyond the merits of the underlying claim. In dismissing the action, Harris J found that several aspects of Tang’s evidence were dishonest and inconsistent with the documentary record.
Those findings subsequently led to separate committal proceedings of criminal contempt at common law by way of false evidence. After reviewing the evidence, Harris J concluded that Tang had knowingly, or at the very least recklessly, given false evidence on five separate occasions. The court held that each instance constituted criminal contempt. In a striking reversal of roles, what began as an attempt by the Company’s liquidator to recover an alleged debt for the Company ultimately resulted in the liquidator of the Company becoming the subject of contempt proceedings.
How the False Evidence Led to Committal Proceedings
Harris J identified five key areas in which Tang’s evidence was inconsistent with the documentary record and the surrounding circumstances.
- First, Tang claimed that some of the Company’s financial records from 1992 to 1999 had been lost, despite never having searched the hundreds of boxes of company documents in the liquidators’ possession.
- Second, he claimed that he had reviewed the Company’s holding company’s accounts but not those of the Company he was liquidating. The court considered this highly implausible given his experience and role.
- Third, Tang suggested that he misunderstood his disclosure obligations and believed that he was only required to disclose documents referred to in witness statements. The court rejected this explanation outright, finding it incompatible with his decades of insolvency and litigation experience.
- Fourth, Tang made an assertion that was contrary to documentary evidence and the Company’s own pleaded case.
- Finally, when challenged on that inconsistency, he claimed that his staff had provided him with the wrong annual return, an explanation for which no supporting evidence was ever produced.
Taken together, the court concluded that these were not innocent mistakes, but instances of false evidence given knowingly, or at least recklessly, against the truth with the conscious intention of interfering with the judicial process by influencing the court’s decision.
Elements of Contempt for Making False Statement – A Divergence on Mental Element: Recklessness Simpliciter
It was held that in citing a person for contempt for making a false statement of truth, each of the following elements must be proved beyond reasonable doubt:
- Element 1: the falsity of the statement in question;
- Element 2: the statement has or would have interfered with the course of justice in some material respect; and
- Element 3: at the time it was made, the maker of the statement had no honest belief in the truth of the relevant statement and knew of its likelihood to interfere with the course of justice. It is not necessary to prove that the defendant has an intent to interfere with the administration of justice. Suffice if the maker of the statement (1) had no honest belief in the truth of the relevant statement and (2) knew of its likelihood to interfere with the administration of justice.
Significantly, the decision highlights an important jurisdictional divergence between Hong Kong and English common laws regarding the mental element for criminal contempt. Harris J affirmed that recklessness simpliciter—affirming facts or giving sworn testimony without caring whether it is true or false—is sufficient to satisfy the mental threshold in Hong Kong. In doing so, the High Court declined to follow the stricter UK Court of Appeal authority in Norman v Adler [2023] EWCA Civ 785, which requires proof of deliberate dishonesty. In other words, there is a lower threshold to satisfy in Hong Kong makes it considerably easier to commit witnesses who make reckless, unverified assertions under oath, reinforcing the strict duty of care owed when swearing evidence before Hong Kong courts.
Liquidators Are Held to a Higher Standard
A recurring theme in the judgments was that liquidators, as officers of the court, are held to particularly high standards of conduct. Harris J emphasized that such officeholders are expected not only to comply with their legal obligations but also to act fairly, honestly and with integrity. The court regarded Tang’s conduct as especially serious because it involved an experienced insolvency practitioner rather than an ordinary commercial litigant.
The decisions reinforce the principle that officers of the court owe duties to the court as well as those appointing them. Their efforts must not come at the expense of candour, objectivity or fairness. Proper investigations, full compliance with disclosure obligations and complete accuracy in sworn evidence remain essential features of the role.
Takeaway
These decisions send a powerful message to officers of the court (including liquidators) and anyone giving evidence on oath in Court that the court is not tolerant of evidence that is knowingly false or recklessly given without regard to the truth.
For officers of the court such as liquidators, the standard is particularly exacting: investigate thoroughly, disclose fully and ensure that every statement made under oath can be supported by the facts. As these cases demonstrate, a witness who departs from that standard risks an extraordinary shift in position, from liquidator of the claimant to contemnor.
For more details, feel free to reach out to:
Managing Partner: Mr. Ian Lo
Consultant: Ms. Crystal Cheung

